Managed open-source total cost calculator
Compare an operated app estate with doing it yourself: licences, infrastructure, migration, recurring cash costs and the value of staff time.
Last updated
In short
- Compare cash expenditure separately from the value of internal time.
- Existing hardware and unused seats are not automatically avoidable costs.
- Count migration, retained tools and upstream licences before calculating payback.
On this page (4)
Costs and savings · Part of Pricing
Interactive worksheet · no sign-up
Estimate Open-source ownership costs
Use the same currency and scope for both options. Inputs stay in this page; they are not included in analytics or sent with an enquiry.
- Current total over selected horizon
- Replacement total, including transition
- Invoice saving over selected horizon
- Economic saving, also valuing internal time
- Simple payback from start
Negative savings mean the replacement costs more under these assumptions. Positive savings do not establish equivalent features, capacity or service levels.
How the calculation works
- Current monthly invoices = billed units × unit price + additional current spend.
- Replacement monthly invoices = Pilae management + additional infrastructure + target licences + workload usage + retained services.
- Transition = plan onboarding + new hardware + extra migration + training + parallel months × max(0, current invoices − retained services). Parallel months are capped at the comparison horizon.
- Total invoices = monthly invoices × horizon, plus transition for the replacement. Payback uses the full transition commitment divided by positive monthly invoice saving, including all entered overlap months even beyond the selected horizon.
- Economic saving adds the change in valued internal operating time. It does not assume headcount reduction.
Business includes up to 3 apps, then a published per-app fee (CHF 390 in CHF). Starter’s published CHF price is CHF 449/month. All Pilae figures come from the same price data as the pricing page. Workload inputs are your estimates, not supplier quotes. Taxes, price growth, discount rates, opportunity costs and differences in functionality are outside this arithmetic.
The useful comparison is the cost of keeping the same business functions working. A software licence, a virtual machine and an operated application buy different things. The calculator on this page puts recurring service costs and transition costs into one model; use the scope checks below before treating its result as a purchasing recommendation.
Set the boundary before entering a price
List the applications, environments and users covered by each option. A production instance with backups is not equivalent to production plus staging, tested recovery and an incident response commitment. Conversely, a small internal tool may not need the most expensive service level.
| Cost line | Current estate | Proposed estate | Evidence to collect |
|---|---|---|---|
| Software | Subscriptions and add-ons actually billed | Required upstream editions and managed-service rights | Invoice and licence terms |
| Infrastructure | Compute, storage, network and recovery copies | Capacity for the agreed architecture | Usage history and quote |
| Operation | Contractors, on-call fees, employee effort | Service fee plus work that stays internal | Contract and time sample |
| Transition | Usually already incurred | Migration, integration, training, overlap | Scoped work estimate |
| Exit | Current export and notice obligations | Data handover and replacement operation | Written exit process |
The Open Source Definition describes freedoms in software distribution; it does not include free hosting, support or indemnity. Some catalogue software is source-available instead. For example, NocoDB’s licence distinguishes internal deployment from commercial managed services. Budget the rights and features the proposed arrangement actually needs.
Keep three views of the answer
Recurring cash cost is what leaves the business each month once the transition is complete. Use the actual net invoice and include retained subscriptions. Cancelling ten seats in a hundred-seat contract does not remove the other ninety.
First-year cash cost includes onboarding, migration, parallel operation, hardware purchases and training. Spread these over a longer period only in a separate amortized view. Cash paid this year remains cash paid this year.
Capacity value estimates employee time released for other work. If an engineer gains twelve hours a month, that is useful capacity. It becomes a cash saving only if it prevents an identifiable expense such as overtime, contractor days or a planned hire. Do not count it twice as both reduced staffing and productivity.
An illustrative comparison
Suppose an estate currently spends 1,800 currency units each month on contracts and infrastructure. A proposed arrangement costs 1,500 monthly and needs 7,200 of transition work. Assume the scope is equivalent and no other costs change.
The recurring cash difference is 300 per month. Year one saves 3,600 on recurring charges but spends 7,200 on transition, leaving an additional 3,600 of cash outlay. Simple payback is 24 months. A twelve-month presentation that calls this a saving hides the timing.
These figures are invented inputs to explain the calculation, not Pilae prices or a customer result. If the current contract cannot end for another six months, add the overlap. If the replacement omits a feature, add the retained service or reject the comparison.
Shared services need an allocation rule
A database, identity service or machine may support several apps. Count the whole bill once at estate level. For app-level decisions, allocate by a stated rule such as reserved capacity, measured resource use or equal shares; then show whether adding the next app changes the bill at all.
An already paid-for server may have zero incremental rental charge but still consume power, backup storage and maintenance. A server at capacity may require a new purchase. Full cost and incremental cost answer different questions, so label them.
Use the current Pilae pricing and a scoped infrastructure estimate. The live model reads the service price centrally; the prose does not freeze a second price list. Before committing, agree the operating responsibility matrix, test representative workloads and record which original contracts can actually end.
Sources and further reading
Use the linked documentation to confirm the version, edition and contract that apply to your project.
